Authoritarians cannot win in a free marketplace of ideas in a healthy liberal democracy. Their methods – to coerce, to deceive, to violate norms, or to inflame populist sentiment – are a confession of their weakness. This is the real story of the Trump administration’s approach to remaking education in America in its own ideological image, a battle it cannot win on the merits. Instead, it exploits fear about the ideologies it opposes and shatters the norms of how government is supposed to work with the education sector.
This is the framework within which to understand the record-size grant by the Trump-controlled National Endowment for the Humanities to the politically conservative Tikvah Fund. It is a bigger story than it appears, and a critically important case study in demonstrating the insecurity of the American right about its ideas, its failure to win by playing fair, and its choice instead to simply break the rules.
Earlier this year, when the NEH cancelled its grants to scholars and institutions across the country, breaking contracts and sending the already-reeling field of the humanities into existential turmoil, the only plausible conservative argument was that it was part of an approach to make government smaller. This would be consistent with classic Republican governance. The government was doing the same to the Department of Education and to other federally-funded institutions. In reallocating these dollars to its friends and boosters, however, the administration admits what we suspected all along: this administration does believe in the role of government to facilitate ideas. It just believes it should ideologically engineer the outcomes.
The key method in all of this, to what should be the Jewish community’s shame and horror, is the manipulation of the Jewish community’s genuine concerns about antisemitism. And yes, there is antisemitism in higher education as well as in the K-12 systems in both public and independent school systems; and yes, some of it is because of ideological authoritarianism on the left which also refuses to play fair in imposing orthodoxies and policing dissent.
But it is astonishing to me how badly the Jewish community is getting played right now. Jewish vulnerabilities are real after October 7, which make Jews desperate to have our fears affirmed and for powerful allies to fight on our behalf; and as a result, many of our leaders and our people are embracing these authoritarian power plays under the morally misguided approach that the ends justify the means. That is just wrong when it comes to the ethos and norms of liberal democracy, and I am genuinely scared that our community is standing idly by as this takes place - sometimes cheering it on - and taking solace in the myth that this is being done for our protection and benefit.
American Jews thrived in this country thanks to the infrastructure of liberal democracy which included ideas, norms, and institutions. We participated actively in building that infrastructure, trusting that this collective enterprise could keep us safe. Now we are watching as the administration not only goes after that infrastructure, but also against some of our best people. In the universities themselves, the Trump administration clawed back millions of dollars in NEH grants from Jewish Studies scholars - some of our best bulwarks in the system against antisemitism! - to give it instead to their ideological allies outside that system. Now some of our best minds and finest scholars are even more vulnerable professionally than they were before, assaulted by both the attack on the financial viability of their institutions as well as by the diminishing of their own capacity for the original research that advances our understanding of what it means to be Jewish. We will have, as a result, weaker, uncompetitive, partisan ideas generated outside the academy meant to fight the ideological battles taking place on the inside. It is as unstrategic as it is malicious.
There will be people who will read this post and think that this is a spat between Hartman and Tikvah, between the liberal and pluralistic institution that I lead and the conservative institution that is the benefit of the administration’s largesse. That is not the point of this critique. Organizations dependent on philanthropy will raise and take money as they see fit, and most organizations have to be opportunists when presented with this kind of windfall. I welcome a principled debate with my ideological opponents, when we all play by the same rules. The marketplace of ideas - and the contest for philanthropic support - should be wide open.
That’s just not what we have here. This, instead, represents an acknowledgment by the hard right that it cannot win fairly, it constitutes a misuse of government resources, and is a betrayal of the terms of liberal democracy. I think the administration will win these short term battles, and I hope they are not doing irreparable damage. And I hope responsible conservatives will see this for what it is, and opt back into a fair fight.




Yehuda, thanks so much for putting your thoughts out there.
I agree with much of what you describe - and the dangers that the current administration poses to liberal democracy. I have both praise for and reservations about the work of Tikvah, the same way I have them towards many other orgs. But as you well put it, this is not a debate about Tikvah.
I think, however, that we need to expand the lens a little more. The same argument you make about the right - that they need to use coercion or government intervention to compete in the marketplace of ideas - can also be said about the left.
A conservative may say "look, DEI ideas are unpopular, and most people oppose, for example, the new gender theories. It grew and became dominant in large part because the government, in past administrations, had embraced and promoted it. People were force-fed a lot of progressive stuff in schools and universities without true debate, and there wasn't a real free marketplace of ideas. Whoever disagreed got "cancelled"" And they'd have a point. Democratic administrations funded organizations and programs towards which they had ideological affinity. The Trump administration is doing it in a more crude and even grotesque way, but Democrats also established ideological litmus tests.
That, of course, doesn't justify what the Trump administration is doing in terms of free speech, etc, but it does place the conversation in a wider context. The government has been putting its finger on the scale for a long time; it's just more evident here. So the question is - how do we make the marketplace of ideas truly free? How do we prevent the government from twisting and denaturalizing the debate? That question becomes more acute during an administration that aspires to autocracy, but it's not unique to it. Both the left and the right aspire to a hegemonic ideological discourse, so how can people like and you and me break that cycle more systemically? Do we promote the idea that any govt funding is "muktze"? (Many orgs don't take govt money by principle).
The second point is that I would have liked you to engage more with the ideas themselves. (And maybe you will in the future). Meaning, it would be helpful to learn why you think that Tikvah ideas - whatever they are - can't win in a free marketplace of ideas. What are the specific ideas that they promote that people reject and can only be mainstream through government intervention? Why is this grant particularly egregious? What is the government seeking to promote when they fund Tikvah - and why is that wrong? If Tikvah was just the "mashal" you used, and not the point in itself, then the same question applies to conservative ideas themselves.
And finally, a more general philosophical point that your piece raises, albeit obliquely - what is today, in our times of epistemic chaos, a "marketplace of ideas"? It seems that it isn't campus, and of course, it's not social media. So, where are ideas debated? By whom? Who manages that marketplace? And if the market becomes unfree due to the hegemonic projects of either the left or the right, what alternative venues can we create?
Sharing ideas with the world is always an act of generosity, so thank you again for publishing and helping to prompt these thoughts, which I'm happy to discuss further.
“Some senior staff do fly business class or first class for travel related to work.” - The Shalom Hartman Institute of N. America, Form 990, Dec 2023.
Some would say that sucking $33m of tax exempt charitable contributions out of the Jewish community in 2023 alone in order to create videos about cooking turkey constitutes “a misuse of resources.” https://fb.watch/w6SHfCsmlg/
If only the NEH knew what it was missing out on here!